Churnkey alternative
A Churnkey alternative with pricing you can see before you talk to sales
Churnkey is a solid failed-payment recovery and cancellation-flow tool — but its pricing is quote-based, which means a sales call before you know what it costs, and often an annual contract.
PaidGuard covers the same core job — Stripe-native failed-payment detection, smart retries, dunning emails, and a recovery dashboard — with pricing listed on the website ($39/mo + 5% of revenue actually recovered) and no annual commitment.
Public pricing vs. quote-based
PaidGuard's price is on the pricing page: $39/mo + 5% of what's recovered. No demo required to find out what you'd pay.
Month-to-month, not annual
Cancel anytime from your dashboard. No annual contract to negotiate out of.
| Feature | PaidGuard | Churnkey | Stunning | Baremetrics | ProfitWell Retain |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pricing transparency (shown upfront) | — | — | — | — | |
| No annual contract required | — | — | — | ||
| Free tier available | See your number free | — | — | — | |
| Custom retry schedules | — | ||||
| Dunning email sequences | 5 stages | ||||
| Email template editor (no code) | 3 tone presets | — | |||
| Revenue calculator / forecasting | — | — | |||
| White-label customer page | — | — | |||
| Multi-PSP support (not just Stripe) | roadmap | — | — | ||
| Public pricing on website | — | — | |||
| Starting price | $39/mo + 5% recovered | Quote-based | Quote-based | $96/mo | Free (acquired by Paddle) |
Frequently asked questions
Why is Churnkey's pricing quote-based?
Churnkey sells to a range of company sizes with varying needs (cancellation flows, feedback surveys, recovery), so its pricing is customized per account — which means you typically need a sales conversation to get a number.
Does PaidGuard do everything Churnkey does?
PaidGuard focuses specifically on failed-payment recovery: retries, dunning emails, and a recovery dashboard. Churnkey additionally offers cancellation-flow and win-back survey tooling that PaidGuard doesn't currently build — if that's your primary need, it's worth weighing both.
Is there an annual contract with PaidGuard?
No. PaidGuard is billed monthly and you can cancel anytime from your dashboard — no multi-year commitment.
Can I see my numbers before committing to either tool?
With PaidGuard, yes — connect Stripe read-only (no card) and see your actual failed-payment total from the last 90 days before deciding anything.
How does the 5% recovery fee compare to a flat quote-based price?
PaidGuard's $39/mo covers the platform; the 5% only applies to money actually recovered, so cost scales with results rather than being a fixed number regardless of outcome. Whether that's cheaper than a specific Churnkey quote depends on your recovery volume — worth running the math for your numbers.
See your real number — no card required
Information based on publicly available sources as of 2026. PaidGuard is not affiliated with Churnkey — this page is provided for comparison purposes only. Verify current pricing and features directly with Churnkey before making a decision.